Ask HN: Why HN logo not in SVG?

11 points | by crehn 2433 days ago

8 comments

  • CM30 2432 days ago
    Probably because it's so small that the benefits of making it an SVG would be almost nil. I mean, look at this thing:

    https://news.ycombinator.com/y18.gif

    It's 0.1KB. It's so small that any SVG version of it would actually be a larger file (seriously, I tested it with an SVG converter script online, and the SVG came back at 0.6KB).

    There's no practical reason to convert it, at least not as far as file size is concerned.

    • krapp 2432 days ago
      The benefits of keeping it a gif would seem to be practically nil as well.
      • dyeje 2431 days ago
        Yea, but changing it takes work and leaving it doesn't.
  • malux85 2431 days ago
    Being a hacker is about knowing when something is good enough.

    It's about focusing on interesting content rather than pixel perfection.

    It's about shipping on Tuesday rather than shipping on Friday.

    It's about optimising the things that are important.

    I like it, even if it's a big pixel-y on hi def displays, it's a reminder that done is better than perfect

    • krapp 2431 days ago
      I don't recall reading any of that in the Hacker Manifesto...
  • brett40324 2430 days ago
    Because 99.9% of users don't care and have or never will pay any attention to it. Just like most other logos, or design aesthetics - they are more perceived than actively thought about by consumers.
  • muzani 2431 days ago
    Because it's not about optimizing every little thing. It's about getting it good enough. And even when something sounds better in theory, it might not be that way in practice.
  • shoo 2433 days ago
    Make a business case for it
    • bananicorn 2431 days ago
      It could get re-used as part of the logo on the main y-combinator site, and the same logo could be cached ;)

      But then again, HN itself is already easily fast enough, and you don't optimize when you don't have to.

      But probably not worth the effort - the extra CSS might mess up the equation.

    • BorisMelnik 2432 days ago
      its a very HN type of thing to do...code an image, that is
    • crehn 2433 days ago
      Looks pretty. Pretty things are nice. Nice things are good.
  • fairpx 2430 days ago
    What would improve for the end user, when it was in SVG?
  • maxraz 2430 days ago
    It could be in .svg for a sharper look on smartphones
  • balazsdavid987 2432 days ago
    Explain the performance benefits
    • Scirra_Tom 2432 days ago
      Probably smaller file size and will look better on hi dpi displays?
    • crehn 2432 days ago
      It looks pretty, not a question of performance.