What the Tortoise Said to Achilles


32 points | by sytelus 72 days ago


  • lisper 71 days ago

    Wrong title. The linked piece is called "What the Tortoise should have said to Achilles." In this case in particular, this makes a huge difference.

    • Iffyphus 71 days ago

      Actually, the piece is called "What Achilles should have said to the Tortoise" still a big difference though.

      • 70 days ago
    • pdmccormick 71 days ago

      "Come a little bit closer and I'll tell you. Come just a little bit closer still and I'll tell you..."

      • jaclaz 70 days ago

        The actual "original" by Lewis Carrol:

        "What the Tortoise Said to Achilles," Mind 4, No. 14 (April 1895): 278-280

        is available online, and should be read before the linked article:


        Solvitur ambulando

        • Retra 70 days ago

          In other words: you can hand someone a proof, but you can't force them to read it. If the tortoise is unwilling to tell you what exactly a proof must entail, then he's effectively not interested in being a rational agent who is compelled to agree to facts logically derived from premises.

          • darkpuma 71 days ago

            The logical conclusion of this is Achilles inventing tortoise soup.